Discover the bold, artisanal flavor of Cheddar Cheese!
Our standout 1795 Signature Cheddar leads the way in this category. This farmstead classic, aged over one year using fresh milk from our own herd, delivers a crumbly yet creamy texture bursting with natural cheese crystals, rich savory notes, and subtle sweet undertones.
Crafted in small batches at our family run, veteran owned farm in Latrobe, Pennsylvania, our Cheddars prioritize sustainability and purity, free from additives. From mild and sharp and with varieties such as our Roasted Garlic or Jalapeño Habanero cheddar, they're perfect for charcuterie boards, melting in mac 'n' cheese, or snacking straight.
Our 1795 Signature Cheddar has garnered recent accolades:
- Bronze Medal at the World Cheese Awards (2024)
- Bronze Medal at the World Cheese Awards (2025)
- 1st Place and Overall 2nd Best of Show at the Pennsylvania Farm Show (2023
Available for nationwide shipping. Order today and taste generations of tradition!
Pick up where you left off