Cheese Makers Selections Gift Box

Curated directly by the artisans who craft our cheese, the Cheesemaker’s Selection Gift Box is our most popular, lavish farmstead spread. Our cheesemakers put together everything they love on their own holiday board, combining multi-award-winning aged cheeses, seasonal specialties, spicy pepper jelly, cured meats, and gourmet sweets into one incredible collection.

What’s Inside:

• 1795 Reserve Cheddar (6 oz) (Award Winner) – Our flagship aged farmstead cheddar, boasting deep complexity, rich umami notes, and a sharp, sweet finish.

• 1976 Signature Aged Gouda (6 oz) (Award Winner) – Aged over a year to develop a sweet, nutty profile with caramel undertones and a delicate crystalline bite.

• Mature Gouda (6 oz) – Firm and richly aged with deep, savory, and caramelized flavor notes.

• Jingle Jack (Seasonal Favorite) – A festive, limited-run favorite crafted to bring holiday cheer to your board.

• Cheesemaker's Choice Flavored Cheddar – A surprise selection from our popular flavored line (like Roasted Garlic, Onion Chive, or Jalapeño Habanero).

• DeLallo Pepperoni – Classic, savory cured pepperoni designed to anchor any charcuterie display.

• Primrose Farms Pepper Jelly (Large Jar) – Locally made pepper jelly bringing the perfect touch of sweet heat to balance rich, aged cheeses.

• Primrose Farms Artisan Jam (Large Jar - Cheesemaker's Choice) – Handcrafted local jam paired to complement our Gouda and Cheddar.

• Large Honey Bear – Pure, golden honey to drizzle over sharp cheddar, Gouda, and warm biscuits.

• Effie’s Premium Oatcakes (7.2 oz) – Lightly sweetened, buttery oat biscuits made for pairing with aged cheeses.

• Sweet and Salty Pecans (3.25 oz) by Fortune Favors – Perfectly candied pecans delivering a rich, buttery crunch.

• Chocolate Covered Mini Pretzels – The ultimate sweet-and-salty snack to round out the spread.

• 6-Pack Chocolate Covered Quark Truffles (Award Winner) – Decadent, melt-in-your-mouth truffles filled with our silky, fresh Quark cheese.